Every time I’m around Gifford, I somehow end up reactivating an online dating profile without remembering how much I despise online dating. It’s the only influence she has over me that I find disconcerting, because it’s in complete, fundamental opposition to how I believe people should interact in this world.

But Gifford is great. If you ever have the opportunity to live with her, you will wake up one Saturday morning to a house full of half naked professional bike racers and a car parked on your front lawn. Or a Post-It note suggestion like this.
I went to Boulder to visit Gifford, and within hours I found myself hunting down eligible bachelors in the greater Denver area. Nothing panned out because I was just browsing without any clear focus. In short, I was surveying the field in my online shopping for dudes.
Then something curious happened. I began to receive a plethora of email from pretty cool guys near home. Despite the fact that in my profile I acknowledge that I am “honest to a fault” and confess that the most private thing I’m willing to share is that “I look at the pictures first, and sometimes I forget to recycle,” cute New England men still desired my attention.

One message I received was particularly interesting. It was a multi-paragraph introduction from a guy with a username who had no profile data filled out and no pictures available. But his argument seemed somewhat convincing. He wrote:
“Hello super spiffy green mountain skier and biker! You seem quite approachable and personable, and I absolutely love the impression of you I get from a good look at your pics so here I am! I’ve just made my profile, but with that, I think if you just don’t appeal to someone, why waste the whole profile/photo thing? Meanwhile if they ARE in fact intrigued, they will probe deeper, including asking to see pictures, which I have and would readily message on over! The name’s Brett. 32 years of age. Reside in Keene, though am originally from an hour north of the Bronx (to have been a Sox fan woulda been equal to sacrilege!). A gemini. Left handed. Outgoing and fun loving. Quick witted and random. Loyal and reliable. Affectionate and cuddly. Usually nice company as I have a wide array of interests and am always game for new experiences! Should on this beautiful weekend you find you might like to communicate with me and learn more, I would in turn find that a reply from you made my entire day
”
Call me a sucker, but I took the bait.

Hook, line, and sinker, I replied:
“Definitely need to see pictures. I believe personalities must match as well, but I’m a very visual person. Thanks for the note.”
He offered up his email address so I could access his Facebook page, and then added: “If still interested, write me back. If not, hey I realize I’m not gonna be everyones cup of tea.”
The grammar mistakes were starting to pain me, but I decided to check out his Facebook profile anyway. That’s where I found his picture.
Wait for it…
-
-
-
-
-
Wait for it…
-
-
-
-
-
Yes, I’m afraid that’s his Super 8 Motel uniform and not a Halloween costume. He has 105 Facebook friends and a high school education. His activities and interests include: “spending time with my son, card games, board games, trivia games, mini golf, snow tubing, Christmas Tree Shops, and going to the ocean.” The only thing we share in common is an appreciation for the Red Hot Chili Peppers and This American Life.
I’ve often sought the proper way to let a guy gently know that I’m not interested without making him sit around for days wondering if a response is going to show up. I decided to play along with his cup of tea colloquialism. I chose my words cautiously and responded:
“Thanks again for your note, but yeah, I’m not really up for tea. Best of luck in your search.”

I have always thought of this as an open and yet still careful manner of sending a man on his way to find the true love of his life. But this dude had an afterthought for me. He countered:
“I dont dig idiots that try to cover up their shallowness with lame wit. Bye.”
Funny, I don’t dig people who forget to use apostrophes in contractions, but I wasn’t going to hold that against him. I like to think of myself as an attractive individual with a lot to offer, but even I know my dating boundaries. I mean, I spend the vast majority of my time skiing down icy mountains and pedaling bikes around the world. What did he think we were going to do together, play Magic: The Gathering and buy Christmas ornaments? He tried to cut me deep. It was uncalled for. I’m not usually one to throw the last dagger, but in this particular instance I could not refuse. I penned this final response which has now become nothing shy of legendary among my friends:
“You live over 50 miles away from me, never went to college, have a kid, and I’m not the least bit attracted to you. I was trying to be kind, but since you decided to play the asshole card, I rescind my best wishes. Try playing in your own league next time.”
Karma’s probably going to keep me on the bench for awhile for that one, but right now it all feels worth it.








